Season 1[]
| Contestant | Episodes | |||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | ||||||
| Candice | Natalie | Bret | LOW | Aaron | Natalie | Trent | Tom | - | Trent | Helen | Christina | Samantha | LOW | Serena | Jonathan | LOW | LOW | LOW | WINNER | |
| Samantha | Shawn | LOW | Anya | Aaron | LOW | Danny | - | Margaret | Dominick | Helen | Andrea | LOW | LOW | Jay | Jonathan | Jay | Alexander | Dominick | RUNNER-UP | |
| Dominick | Natalie | Trent | Candice | Alexander | Samantha | Trent | Tom | - | LOW | Helen | Andrea | Brenda | Serena | Jay | Jonathan | Jay | Alexander | OUT | Samantha | |
| Alexander | Shawn | Bret | Candice | LOW | LOW | Danny | - | Jay | Dominick | Helen | Christina | LOW | Andrea | Serena | Jonathan | Candice | OUT | Candice | ||
| Jay | Shawn | Trent | Candice | Aaron | Natalie | Danny | - | LOW | Dominick | LOW | Christina | Samantha | Andrea | LOW | LOW | OUT | Candice | |||
| Jonathan | Shawn | Bret | Candice | Alexander | Natalie | Danny | Tom | - | Trent | Helen | Christina | Brenda | Serena | Serena | OUT | Samantha | ||||
| Serena | Shawn | Bret | Candice | Alexander | Natalie | Danny | Tom | - | Dominick | Helen | Christina | Samantha | LOW | OUT | Candice | |||||
| Andrea | Shawn | Bret | Anya | Aaron | Samantha | Trent | - | Margaret | Trent | Helen | LOW | Brenda | OUT | Candice | ||||||
| Brenda | Shawn | Bret | Candice | Aaron | Natalie | Danny | LOW | - | Dominick | Helen | Christina | OUT | Candice | |||||||
| Christina | Natalie | Trent | Candice | Alexander | Samantha | Trent | - | Margaret | Trent | Helen | OUT | Samantha | ||||||||
| Helen | Shawn | Bret | Anya | Aaron | Samantha | Trent | - | Margaret | Trent | OUT | Samantha | |||||||||
| Trent | Shawn | LOW | Anya | Aaron | LOW | LOW | Tom | - | OUT | |||||||||||
| Margaret | Shawn | Trent | LOW | Aaron | Natalie | Danny | - | OUT | ||||||||||||
| Tom | Shawn | Trent | Anya | Aaron | Samantha | Trent | OUT | |||||||||||||
| Danny | Natalie | Bret | Anya | Aaron | Natalie | OUT | ||||||||||||||
| Natalie | LOW | LOW | Anya | Aaron | OUT | |||||||||||||||
| Aaron | Shawn | Bret | Anya | OUT | ||||||||||||||||
| Anya | Shawn | Trent | OUT | |||||||||||||||||
| Bret | Shawn | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| Shawn | OUT | |||||||||||||||||||