Season 15[]
| Contestants | Week | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | |||||
| Andy | David | Nick | Jeremy | Kaitlin | Howard | Candice | Judd | HOH | Helen | NOM | Amanda | Elissa | Judd | HOH | Spencer | WINNER |
| GinaMarie | Elissa | Elissa | Jeremy | NOM | Howard | HOH | Judd | Jessie | Helen | Aaryn | Amanda | NOM | NOM | McCrae | NOM | RUNNER-UP |
| Spencer | David | Nick | NOM | Kaitlin | Candice | NOM | NOM | NOM | NOM | Aaryn | NOM | Elissa | HOH | NOM | OUT | |
| McCrae | HOH | Nick | Jeremy | Kaitlin | Howard | Candice | Judd | Jessie | Helen | Aaryn | Spencer | HOH | Judd | OUT | ||
| Judd | David | Nick | Jeremy | HOH | Howard | Candice | OUT | Aaryn | Amanda | Elissa | OUT | |||||
| Elissa | NOM | NOM | Jeremy | Kaitlin | Howard | Candice | Judd | Jessie | Spencer | HOH | Spencer | OUT | ||||
| Amanda | David | Nick | Jeremy | Kaitlin | NOM | NOM | Judd | Jessie | Helen | Aaryn | OUT | |||||
| Aaryn | Elissa | HOH | NOM | NOM | HOH | Candice | HOH | Jessie | HOH | OUT | ||||||
| Helen | David | NOM | HOH | Kaitlin | Howard | Candice | Judd | Jessie | OUT | |||||||
| Jessie | NOM | Nick | Jeremy | Kaitlin | Howard | Candice | Judd | OUT | ||||||||
| Candice | Elissa | Nick | Jeremy | Kaitlin | NOM | OUT | ||||||||||
| Howard | David | Elissa | Jeremy | Kaitlin | OUT | |||||||||||
| Kaitlin | Elissa | Elissa | Spencer | OUT | ||||||||||||
| Jeremy | Elissa | Elissa | OUT | |||||||||||||
| Nick | David | OUT | ||||||||||||||
| David | OUT | |||||||||||||||
Season 16[]
| Contestants | Week | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | |||||
| Derrick | Joey | Paola | HOH | Brittany | Amber | Jocasta | Hayden | Nicole | Zach | Donny | Nicole | HOH | - | Frankie | HOH | NOM | WINNER |
| Cody | Joey | Paola | Devin | HOH | Amber | Jocasta | Nicole | Nicole | NOM | HOH | Nicole | Christine | NOM | Frankie | Caleb | Victoria | RUNNER-UP |
| Victoria | Joey | Paola | Devin | Brittany | Amber | Jocasta | Hayden | Nicole | Zach | Donny | NOM | NOM | NOM | NOM | NOM | OUT | |
| Caleb | HOH | Paola | NOM | Brittany | Amber | Jocasta | HOH | Nicole | Zach | Donny | HOH | Christine | - | HOH | OUT | ||
| Frankie | Joey | Paola | Devin | Brittany | HOH | Jocasta | Hayden | Nicole | HOH | Donny | Nicole | Christine | HOH | OUT | |||
| Christine | Joey | Paola | Devin | Brittany | Amber | Jocasta | Hayden | HOH | Zach | Donny | Nicole | OUT | |||||
| Nicole | Joey | Paola | Devin | Brittany | Amber | HOH | NOM | OUT | NOM | OUT | |||||||
| Donny | Joey | Zach | Devin | NOM | Amber | Zach | Nicole | NOM | Zach | OUT | |||||||
| Zach | Joey | NOM | Devin | Brittany | Amber | NOM | Hayden | Nicole | OUT | ||||||||
| Hayden | Joey | Paola | Devin | Brittany | Amber | Zach | OUT | ||||||||||
| Jocasta | Joey | Zach | Devin | Brittany | NOM | OUT | |||||||||||
| Amber | Joey | Paola | Devin | Brittany | OUT | ||||||||||||
| Brittany | Joey | Paola | Devin | OUT | |||||||||||||
| Devin | Joey | HOH | OUT | ||||||||||||||
| Paola | NOM | OUT | |||||||||||||||
| Joey | OUT | ||||||||||||||||
Season 17[]
| Contestants | Week | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | |||||
| Austin | Jace | Da'Vonne | Jeff | John | Jason | Clay | Shelli | Jackie | Becky | HOH | |||||||
| James | HOH | Da'Vonne | NOM | Audrey | Becky | HOH | Shelli | Jackie | Becky | ||||||||
| John | Jace | Da'Vonne | James | NOM | Jason | Clay | Shelli | Jackie | NOM | ||||||||
| Julia | Competed as Liz | Clay | Shelli | Jackie | Becky | ||||||||||||
| Liz | Jace | Da'Vonne | James | Audrey | Jason | Clay | Shelli | Jackie | HOH | ||||||||
| Meg | Jace | NOM | Jeff | Audrey | Becky | Clay | Shelli | NOM | Becky | ||||||||
| Steve | Jace | Da'Vonne | James | Audrey | Jason | Clay | Shelli | HOH | Becky | ||||||||
| Vanessa | Jace | Da'Vonne | HOH | Audrey | HOH | Clay | NOM | Jackie | Becky | ||||||||
| Becky | Jace | - | Jeff | Audrey | NOM | Clay | HOH | Meg | OUT | ||||||||
| Jackie | NOM | - | James | Audrey | Jason | Clay | Shelli | OUT | |||||||||
| Shelli | Jace | HOH | Jeff | HOH | Jason | NOM | OUT | ||||||||||
| Clay | Jace | Da'Vonne | Jeff | Audrey | Jason | OUT | |||||||||||
| Jason | Jace | Meg | Jeff | Audrey | OUT | ||||||||||||
| Audrey | Jackie | Meg | Jeff | OUT | |||||||||||||
| Jeff | Jace | - | OUT | ||||||||||||||
| Da'Vonne | Jace | OUT | |||||||||||||||
| Jace | OUT | ||||||||||||||||